Stoeber Agency · Compass
Compare holding a rental with selling and investing the proceeds. Use the financial picture alongside your need for flexibility, available time and plans for what comes next.
Your numbers
The property you own
If you rent it out
% of rent. Set 0 if self-managing.
Enter your current annual property-tax amount.
Illustrative share of modeled property value. Adjust for the actual property.
If you sell now
Enter an estimate from your tax advisor. This tool does not calculate sale taxes.
Assumptions
All prefilled figures are illustrative. Replace them with your estimates and test a range of outcomes. Appreciation and investment returns can be negative.
What sale proceeds could earn invested.
Hold vs sell
This is a scenario model, not a forecast. It applies the same entered sale-tax amount to a sale now or later, without calculating tax liability. Property tax grows by an assumed 2% annually and insurance by 3%; maintenance follows modeled home value. Rental cash flow is added at year-end, and deficits reduce the modeled investment balance. HOA charges, major costs beyond entered maintenance and rental income-tax effects are excluded. Mortgage payments must cover at least monthly interest. This comparison requires nonnegative proceeds if sold today. Review the costs and tax assumptions for your property before relying on the result.
Alexander Stoeber · DRE #02090649 · Compass
Deciding what to do with a property
The financial gap is one part of this decision. Holding a rental also commits capital, attention and resources. Selling can create flexibility for another home or another priority. Your attachment to the property and your plans deserve a place in the conversation.
Run several realistic scenarios. Then ask which responsibilities you want, how much uncertainty you can comfortably carry and what the next chapter requires. Use the numbers to inform that choice.
Compare realistic financial scenarios, then weigh them alongside your plans, liquidity needs and willingness to manage a rental. This tool estimates outcomes under your inputs; it does not determine the right decision for your life.
Start with the likely rent, ownership costs, net sale proceeds and how long you might hold. Test lower growth and higher costs as well as your expected case. Consider the work, reserves and flexibility each path requires.
Either path can lead in this model. Rent, vacancy, costs, appreciation and investment returns all matter. The final-year result does not imply the same path leads in every earlier year.
Consider maintenance, vacancy, management time or fees, reserves and the obligations that apply to the property and tenancy. This model cannot capture every cost or responsibility. Review the actual requirements before deciding.
The tool subtracts your entered sale-tax estimate from both a sale today and a sale at the end of a future year. That is a simplification, not a tax calculation. Actual sale taxes can differ between the two paths; obtain estimates from a qualified tax professional.
It excludes rental income-tax effects, HOA charges and major costs beyond the entered maintenance allowance. Property tax and insurance use fixed annual growth assumptions. Review these limitations and the actual property costs alongside the chart.
It is a planning scenario based on the numbers entered. Values, rent, costs and investment returns can differ from those assumptions. Use it to identify the questions and evidence needed for a property-specific decision.
Understood. Pursued. Informed. Bring the property questions and the priorities behind your decision. Let’s explore what’s possible.